We objectively compare products. We may earn a commission if you buy via our links.
Homestyles Captiva 48" Outdoor Patio Dining Table…
vsPHI VILLA 37 Inch Outdoor Dining Table Metal…
Loading chart...
81homestyles
80PHI VILLA
Why is Homestyles Captiva 48" Outdoor Patio Dining Table for 4, Aluminum Round Table with Umbrella Hole for Deck Lawn Garden Backyard, Gray better than PHI VILLA 37 Inch Outdoor Dining Table Metal Steel Slat Square Patio Dining Table with 1.57" Umbrella Hole for Garden, Backyard and Porch (Classic Black)?
1 points higher editorial score than nearest rival
81 points vs 80 points
1% better weather resistance
88% vs 87%
1 lbs lighter than heaviest competitor
31.9 lbs vs 32.9 lbs
Cast aluminum frame withstands outdoor elements.
Performance Tests
Homestyles Captiva 48" Outdoor Patio Dining Table for 4, Aluminum Round Table with Umbrella Hole for Deck Lawn Garden Backyard, Gray
PHI VILLA 37 Inch Outdoor Dining Table Metal Steel Slat Square Patio Dining Table with 1.57" Umbrella Hole for Garden, Backyard and Porch (Classic Black)
Structural Durability
84
88
Weather Resistance
88
87
Ergonomic Comfort
62
62
Value Assessment
91
80
Dimensions & Raw Specs
Spec
homestyles
PHI VILLA
Material
Aluminum
Metal
Weight
31.9 lbs
32.9 lbs
Width
48 in
37 in
Length
48 in
37 in
Price
N/A
N/A
📊 Full Comparison Table
All metrics side-by-side for easy comparison
| Metric | Homestyles Captiva 48" Outdoor Patio… | PHI VILLA 37 Inch Outdoor Dining Table… |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 81/100 | 80/100 |
| Durability | 84/100 | 88/100 |
| Weather Resistance | 88/100 | 87/100 |
| Comfort | 62/100 | 62/100 |
| Value | 91/100 | 80/100 |
| Material | Aluminum | Metal |
| Weight | 31.9 lbs | 32.9 lbs |
| Dimensions (W×L) | 48"D × 48"W × 28.75"H | 37"D × 37"W × 28"H |
| Price | View Deal → | View Deal → |
| Brand | homestyles | PHI VILLA |
Final Algorithmic Verdict
Based on pure objective metrics and price-to-value ratio, Homestyles Captiva 48" Outdoor Patio Dining Table… is the superior choice in this 2-way matchup.
Buy Winner on Amazon →More outdoor dining tables Comparisons
PIZZELLO Patio Dining Table fo...vsSERWALL 8-Piece Patio Dining S...PIZZELLO Patio Dining Table fo...vsYITAHOME Aluminum Patio Dining...Homestyles Captiva 48" Outdoor...vsPIZZELLO Patio Dining Table fo...LUCKYERMORE Outdoor Dining Tab...vsPIZZELLO Patio Dining Table fo...PHI VILLA 37 Inch Outdoor Dini...vsPIZZELLO Patio Dining Table fo...DWVO Cast Aluminum Outdoor Din...vsPIZZELLO Patio Dining Table fo...